The Sisters, the Architect, and the Carpenter
The story begins in 1852, when the Sisters of Loretto answered Bishop Jean Baptiste Lamy's call to come west and educate the daughters of Santa Fe. They founded the Loretto Academy on this site and, by the early 1870s, wanted a proper chapel for the school. Lamy, a Frenchman who had earlier hired French stonemasons for his cathedral project up the street, brought in Antoine Mouly to design a Gothic Revival chapel in miniature, modeled on Sainte-Chapelle. Construction took five years and produced a structure of cut sandstone with ribbed-vault ceiling effects rendered in painted lath and plaster — a remarkable feat of Gothic detailing in the middle of the adobe Southwest.
When the chapel was finished in 1878, however, there was a problem. The architect had died (or returned to France, depending on the source) before the choir loft was completed, and the loft itself sat 20 feet above the chapel floor with no staircase. Conventional stairs would consume too much of the tiny nave, and the loft was too high for a ladder. The Sisters, the story goes, made a novena to St. Joseph, the patron saint of carpenters. On the ninth day, an itinerant carpenter appeared at the door with a donkey and a few hand tools, asked for the job, and worked alone for several months. When the staircase was complete, he is said to have left without payment and without giving his name.
Modern researchers have offered a more grounded candidate: Francois-Jean Rochas, a French-born craftsman who lived in northern New Mexico in the late 19th century and was murdered at his homestead in 1895. Period account books and a death notice that called him "the man who built the staircase at the Loretto Chapel" support the case. But the Sisters' original records remain silent, and the chapel today preserves both versions of the story — pious mystery and historical reconstruction — side by side. Visitors are welcome to choose.
